Gang Rape Acquittal: Supreme Court Sets Aside Conviction

Date:

The Supreme Court has set aside the conviction of four men in a 1998 gang rape case. The Court held that the sole testimony of the prosecutrix did not inspire confidence.

A Bench of Justice Pankaj Mithal and Justice Prasanna B. Varale heard the appeal. The appeal challenged the Uttarakhand High Court’s judgment, which had upheld the conviction of the appellants for rape and for intimidating the victim-prosecutrix.

In 2000, the trial court convicted all four accused. It sentenced them to ten years of rigorous imprisonment and also imposed fines. The Uttarakhand High Court upheld that conviction in 2012.

During the pendency of the appeal before the Supreme Court, two of the accused died.

Prosecution Case in Supreme Court: Gang Rape Conviction Acquittal

According to the prosecution, the victim submitted a written complaint on July 31, 1998, to the Senior Superintendent of Police, Dehradun. The complaint concerned an incident that allegedly took place on April 7, 1998.

In her complaint, she said that at about 7:30 pm, she was returning home from the market in Sanjay Colony. At that point, four men—Rajendra, Pappu alias Hanuman, Sushil Kumar and Kishan—intercepted her.

She alleged that the accused gagged her and covered her eyes with a black handkerchief. She said they forcibly took her to a nearby plot. There, according to her, the men raped her one after another.

She also said that she did not report the incident earlier. According to her, the accused had threatened her with serious consequences if she disclosed what had happened.

Defence Arguments in Supreme Court Gang Rape Conviction Acquittal

Before the Supreme Court, the defence argued that the prosecutrix lodged the complaint only about three months. It said this delay weakened the prosecution’s case.

The defence also argued that she had not disclosed the incident to any family member because of shame. Instead, she claimed to have narrated it to an unknown woman. She could not recall that woman’s identity. According to the defence, this prevented them from examining her as a witness.

The appellants also pointed to inconsistencies in the prosecutrix’s statements at different stages. In one version, she said the incident took place in a room. In another, she said it took place in a plot.

The defence also highlighted contradictions about the place of occurrence and other surrounding circumstances.

It further argued that the alleged incident took place near a densely populated area. Yet, the prosecution did not produce any independent witnesses.

The defence also said that prior enmity existed between the parties because of a water supply dispute. According to it, that could have led to false implication.

Findings in the Supreme Court Gang Rape Conviction Acquittal

In the judgment authored by Justice Varale, the Court found the prosecutrix’s conduct unnatural. It noted that she claimed to have disclosed the incident to an unknown outsider instead of a family member.

The Court observed, “the prosecutrix did not disclose the incident to anybody, neither friends nor family nor even her husband, out of shame and ignorance, as mentioned in the complaint. This version of the prosecutrix is against the natural conduct of the person. It would have been natural for the prosecutrix to disclose the incident to her family members after some time and not to somebody unknown to her, and as such it is very difficult to accept the version of the prosecutrix.”

The Bench reiterated that a conviction can rest on the sole testimony of the prosecutrix. However, that testimony must inspire the confidence of the Court.

The Court said, “It is the trite in law that the conviction can rest on the solitary version of the prosecutrix, provided it inspires confidence in the Court. In the present case, the version of the prosecutrix utterly fails to inspire confidence in this Court.”

The Bench found it unsafe to rely on her sole testimony. It especially noted the absence of corroborative evidence and the delay of nearly three months in filing the complaint.

Vijayan Precedent in Supreme Court Gang Rape Conviction Acquittal

The Supreme Court relied on Vijayan v. State of Kerala, (2008) 14 SCC 763. In that case, the prosecution rested only on the testimony of the prosecutrix. There was also a delay of seven months in lodging the FIR. In the absence of corroborative evidence, the accused were acquitted.

Quoting from Vijayan, the Court noted: “In cases where the sole testimony of the prosecutrix is available, it is very dangerous to convict the accused, especially when the prosecutrix could have waited for seven months to file the FIR for rape. This leaves the accused totally defenceless. Had the prosecutrix lodged the complaint soon after the incident, there would have been some supporting evidence, like the medical report or any other injury on the body of the prosecutrix, to show the sign of rape. If the prosecutrix has willingly submitted herself to sexual intercourse and waited for seven months for filing the FIR, it will be very hazardous to convict on such sole oral testimony.”

Applying that principle, the Court held that no medical evidence or other evidence on record proved the prosecution’s case.

The Court observed, “…here is no medical evidence, or any other evidence on record to prove that the accused persons committed the grave act. The ratio in the case of Vijayan (supra) squarely covers the case at hand. We, therefore, do not find any reason whatsoever to hold that the appellants committed the heinous act. The material on record does not clearly establish the guilt of the accused person, and the prosecution has not proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt. We therefore allow the present appeal and set aside the judgment and order of the High Court.”

Accordingly, the Court allowed the appeal.

Cause Title: Rajendra & Ors v. State of Uttarakhand
Citation: 2026 INSC 243

Also Read: Kejriwal Liquor Policy Case Transfer Plea: SC Move

spot_img

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Supreme Court Requests to Courts and Tribunals Carry Binding Force: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court of India has clarified that courts...

Supreme Court Allows Extension of Arbitral Mandate Even After Expiry and Award

The Supreme Court of India has clarified the law...

Clickb Expands South India Presence with Three New Branches in Kochi, Coimbatore and North Kerala

Business registration and intellectual property services platform strengthens its...

MP High Court: Absence of Suicide Note No Ground to Discharge Accused in Abetment Case

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that the...