Supreme Court Upholds Kerala HC Verdict

Date:

The Supreme Court has held that Cochin International Airport Limited (CIAL) is a “public authority” under the Right to Information Act, 2005. The ruling brings CIAL within the ambit of the transparency law.

A Bench of Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Sandeep Mehta dismissed CIAL’s challenge to the Kerala High Court judgment. The Court observed that the High Court’s decision promotes transparency and requires no interference. However, it set aside the ₹1 lakh cost imposed on CIAL’s Managing Director.

Background of the Dispute

The controversy began in 2019 when the State Information Commission ruled that CIAL qualifies as a public authority under the RTI Act. It directed the company to provide certain information.

CIAL challenged the decision before the Kerala High Court. The company argued that the State Government does not control its decision-making. It contended that the Board of Directors exercises ultimate authority under the Articles of Association.

CIAL also pointed out that the Kerala Government holds only 32.42% of its paid-up share capital. It further argued that dividends paid to the government have exceeded its original investment.

Government Control and Financial Support

The respondents highlighted the State Government’s involvement in CIAL’s functioning. They referred to financial assistance and guarantees extended by the government.

The Kerala Government stood guarantor for a bridge loan of ₹100 million from Federal Bank. HUDCO also granted a ₹1 billion term loan backed by a State Government guarantee. Repayment began in 2000 after the airport became operational.

Kerala High Court’s Findings

In December 2022, a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court upheld the State Information Commission’s order. The Court held that CIAL’s objectives and its Articles of Association reveal deep and pervasive government control.

A Division Bench later dismissed CIAL’s writ appeals. The Bench examined the origin of CIAL’s predecessor, the Kochi International Airport Society (KIAS). The State had established KIAS through a government order issued by the District Collector of Ernakulam.

The Court also noted that the State acquired land for the airport in KIAS’s name. It later transferred the land to CIAL. The Bench concluded that the Government exercises control over CIAL’s management and affairs. It directed CIAL to process pending RTI applications within the statutory timelines.

Supreme Court’s Final Order

CIAL approached the Supreme Court against the High Court judgment. The apex court had earlier stayed the ruling.

With the present order, the Supreme Court has now affirmed the High Court’s decision. CIAL will therefore remain subject to the RTI Act. However, the Court removed the monetary cost imposed earlier.

The case is titled M/s Cochin International Airport Limited v. The State Information Commission and Anr.

spot_img

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Supreme Court Requests to Courts and Tribunals Carry Binding Force: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court of India has clarified that courts...

Supreme Court Allows Extension of Arbitral Mandate Even After Expiry and Award

The Supreme Court of India has clarified the law...

Clickb Expands South India Presence with Three New Branches in Kochi, Coimbatore and North Kerala

Business registration and intellectual property services platform strengthens its...

MP High Court: Absence of Suicide Note No Ground to Discharge Accused in Abetment Case

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that the...