The Article 142 Pension Benefits issue came before the Supreme Court after an employee lost his Scheduled Tribe certificate. The Court protected his pension and retiral benefits after more than 30 years of service.
A two-judge bench comprising Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi delivered the ruling. The bench upheld the invalidation of the employee’s ‘Tokre Koli’ ST certificate. However, it protected his earned service benefits under Article 142 of the Constitution.
Supreme Court Grants Relief Under Article 142
The Supreme Court invoked Article 142 to do complete justice in the case.
The employee entered public service in October 1994. He continued working until his retirement on June 30, 2025.
The Court found that denying his pension after such long service would cause serious hardship. It therefore protected his retiral and pensionary benefits.
The Court considered his more than three decades of continuous service. It also considered his retirement after the prolonged legal dispute.
Employee Joined Service in 1994
Shirish Pandharinath Patil joined the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai as a Junior Engineer (Civil). He received the appointment on October 21, 1994.
He secured the post against a reserved vacancy. His community certificate identified him as a member of the ‘Tokre Koli’ Scheduled Tribe.
The competent Caste Scrutiny Committee examined his certificate in 2020. The committee later declared the certificate invalid.
Patil challenged that decision before the Bombay High Court. The High Court upheld the scrutiny committee’s findings.
He then approached the Supreme Court through a Special Leave Petition.
Supreme Court Allows Him to Complete Service
During the appeal, the Supreme Court passed an interim order. That order allowed Patil to continue in service.
He remained in service until June 30, 2025. He then reached the age of superannuation.
After retirement, he sought protection for his pension and other retiral benefits.
Court Relies on Earlier Judgments
The Supreme Court maintained the findings against Patil’s ST certificate.
However, the bench examined whether it could protect his service benefits. The Court relied on earlier decisions concerning Article 142.
The bench referred to Surekha Baljorsingh Thakur v. Caste Scrutiny Committee & Anr. (2024).
It also relied on Chairman and Managing Director, Food Corporation of India & Ors. v. Jagdish Balaram Bahira & Ors. (2017).
Those decisions recognise the Court’s power to grant exceptional relief under Article 142. The power helps the Court achieve complete justice in suitable cases.
Pension Benefits Protected Without Validating Caste Claim
The Supreme Court directed authorities to count Patil’s service from October 21, 1994, to June 30, 2025.
The protection applies only to the calculation and release of his retiral and pensionary benefits. The Court directed authorities to follow the applicable service rules.
The Article 142 Pension Benefits ruling does not validate Patil’s caste claim.
Court Places Strict Conditions on Relief
The Supreme Court clearly limited the relief.
The protection does not recognise Patil as a member of the ‘Tokre Koli’ Scheduled Tribe. It also does not validate his invalidated caste certificate.
Neither Patil nor his family members can claim future benefits based on that certificate.
The Supreme Court therefore partly allowed the appeal. It protected his pension and retiral benefits while keeping the caste certificate invalid.

