The Delhi High Court refused to condone a 281-day delay in filing a criminal revision petition. The Court said litigants cannot keep petitions pending under office objections for long periods just to protect limitation.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma passed the order while hearing a criminal revision that challenged a trial court order. The trial court had earlier set aside the summoning of the accused in a forgery case.
What Happened
The petitioner first filed a criminal revision petition, but the Registry returned it with office objections. The petitioner did not cure the defects for several months. Later, the petitioner withdrew that petition on 27 May 2025, citing typographical mistakes and issues such as improper bookmarking of annexures. The petitioner then filed a fresh revision petition.
What the Petitioner Argued
The petitioner asked the Court to treat the date of the first (defective) filing as the relevant date for limitation. In other words, the petitioner wanted the Court to compute limitation from the initial filing date.
Why the Court Rejected the Plea
The High Court rejected the request. It held that the petition counts as effectively filed only when the party properly re-presents it after curing defects, not when it is first filed in a defective form.
The Court noted that the earlier petition stayed under objections and was ultimately withdrawn. It said accepting the petitioner’s stand would allow litigants to file a petition, leave it defective for months, and later claim the benefit of the earlier filing date. The Court said the law cannot permit this.
The Court also pointed out that the defects were basic (typographical issues and bookmarking/annexure deficiencies). The petitioner did not explain why they could not fix those issues promptly. Finding no “sufficient cause,” the Court dismissed the application seeking condonation of delay.
Case Details
Case Title: Ms. X v. State
Appearances
- For the Petitioner: Mr. Shahrukh Alam, Mr. Shantanu Singh, Mr. Anupam Kirti, Mr. Akshat Chaitanya, Advocates
- For the State: Mr. Naresh Kumar Chahar, APP, with Ms. Amisha Dahiya, Advocate
- For Respondent No. 2: Mr. Sandeep Kapur, Mr. Rose Verma, Advocates
- For Respondent No. 3: Mr. Vikas Pahwa, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Sandeep Kapur, Mr. Jugal Wadhwa, Mr. Rose Verma, Mr. Raghav Goel, Ms. Priyal Jain, Advocates

